Hermes Eau de Mandarine Ambree ~ fragrance review

Hermès Eau de Mandarine Ambrée

Eau de Mandarine Ambrée is one of two new 2013 offerings in the unisex Cologne Collection at Hermès, the other being Eau de Narcisse Bleu. Both were developed by house perfumer Jean-Claude Ellena, who notes that Mandarine Ambrée "is quite immediate, the other [Narcisse Bleu] is more complex.” The same contrast might be drawn between the last two additions to the series, Eau de Pamplemousse Rose and Eau de Gentiane Blanche,1 and once again, I find that I prefer the immediate: Eau de Mandarine Ambrée is easily my favorite; Eau de Narcisse Bleu, like Gentiane Blanche, is arguably the more interesting of the pair but was just a tad too mild for my tastes.2

Mandarine Ambrée, which features mandarin, passion fruit and amber, has a similar sparkling start as the Pamplemousse Rose, albeit with much less (but surely some) grapefruit. It's bright and cheerful, with a beautifully juicy and tart mandarin note that gradually gets fruitier, fuller and sweeter, and then slightly woody, with a sheer amber base and a slight dash of vanilla. It isn't heavy, and indeed it smells suspiciously like something that is bound to be fleeting, but it isn't — a few good sprays lasted for hours on me, and even the citrus and fruity notes linger far longer than you'd expect.

Again like Pamplemousse Rose, Mandarine Ambrée is a cologne in the classic sense, in contrast to the more modern approach taken with Gentiane Blanche and Narcisse Bleu. Presumably, you know who you are and which you'll be likely to prefer, but I do think both are worth a shot.

Verdict: I knew within 15 minutes that Narcisse Bleu was not for me, but I wasn't immediately sure about Mandarine Ambrée. As sometimes happens, it grew on me with subsequent wearings. I'd add it to my buy list if I needed another summer cologne from Hermès, or if they offered it in a (much) smaller size,3 but as it is I will probably do without it until I drain my bottle of Pamplemousse Rose, and maybe replace my almost-empty bottle of Osmanthe Yunnan. Thinking of Angie's recent post on Day to Night Perfume for Summer, Mandarine Ambrée would make a perfect daytime pair with Hermès L’Ambre des Merveilles for evening, and if my sample holds out, I might try layering it with some others in the Merveilles series — it could be that it would do nicely with Eau Claire.

Hermès Eau de Mandarine Ambrée is available in 100 ($125) and 200 ($165) ml Eau de Toilette.

1. Both launched in 2009, and joined the older 1979 classic Eau d’Orange Verte.

2. That said, the opening of Narcisse Bleu is really quite stunning, and it's worth trying if only for the unusual take on bitter greenery in the first few minutes, which inspired Victoria at Bois de Jasmin to quote Monty Python's "we want a shrubbery". After that, it's a much milder experience, although the narcissus note is likewise quite nicely done. There's another positive review of Narcisse Bleu at Grain de Musc. If you'd like another take on the Mandarine Ambrée, check out Persolaise.

3. Hermès does frequently produce 15 ml travel sizes, sometimes as limited editions. If I come across one for Mandarine Ambrée, it will be mine.

Shop for perfume

FragranceNetParfums Raffy

33 Comments

Leave a comment, or read more about commenting at Now Smell This. Here's a handy emoticon chart.

  1. jonr951 says:

    Ok, this one sounds like a must have! I have been waiting patiently for it to make it to Nordstrom and it FINALLY has! I adore my Pamplemousse Rose and seeing as how it’s my ONLY summer cologne, does the Mugler cologne count?, I think I can afford to invest in another one if this one is as fabulous as it sounds. Thanks for the great review Robin! : )

    • Robin says:

      Hey, the Mugler definitely counts — another one of my favorites, and WAY cheaper than the Hermes, right?

      • jonr951 says:

        Oh yes, WAY cheaper! I actually got my bottle as a free gift at a Mugler event at Nordstrom. Well, what with what I had to purchase to qualify for the free gift, it sure wasn’t completely free. Haha! : )

        • Robin says:

          It can also be bought at discount for a song, in case your bottle ever runs out.

          • jonr951 says:

            Oh it’s going to! My brother just recently fell for it and he’s been draining my precious bottle in the immense heat that we’ve been having here in southern CA! Thank goodness he does not know about my Pamplemousse Rose! Muahahahaha! ; )

            Oh, and did u ever try the edt of Pamplemousse Rose Robin?! I have yet to find it and have no idea how it compares to the original. Dying to give it a test! : (

          • Robin says:

            Hey, now I’m confused…I didn’t think PR came in any format but Eau de Toilette?

          • relleric says:

            I’ve seen the EDP at NM, the bottle is frosted instead of clear (EDT). In my case, the EDT of EdPR is plenty strong enough.

          • jonr951 says:

            My bottle says Eau de Cologne and the frosted one, which is the newer one, says Eau de Toilette. Are cologne and toilette the same thing, and I haven’t had a clue this whole time? Haha! : )

          • Robin says:

            Relleric, thank you…honestly did not know (or had forgotten) there was an EdP.

            Jonr951: Usually EdC is a little lighter in concentration. And you are right…I thought the original was an EdT, but just looked at my bottle and it is EdC, and the clear bottle. So I think it was originally an EdC and later they did an EdT?

          • jonr951 says:

            Thanks for the info Robin! : )

            I really don’t think it comes in an EdP, the frosted bottle is the EdT, but it would be interesting to compare all 3 if it did.

            I have yet to find the EdT in-store, but here’s hoping I do because I really would love to compare the two. Although, I really don’t have any complaints about the EdC’s staying power. : )

      • Joe says:

        Note that the EdT is actually what I’d consider a flanker: Concentré de Pamplemousse Rose

        • Robin says:

          Thanks Joe. I’ll have to see if my local H. boutique has it.

          • relleric says:

            Now I’m confused. I must have the EdC, as my bottle is clear. I could have sworn it said (or maybe the SA said) EDP on that frosted bottle…
            Anyway, the EdC is strong enough for me! :)

  2. Ysbrand says:

    Hmmm, i was the opposite… the Narcisse Bleu went right to the highest places on my shopping list, while i didn´t care so much for the mandarine… although i admit is a very nicely done fragance, specially because the lasting power of the citrusy notes is truly outstanding!

    • Robin says:

      I’m sure many people will prefer the Narcisse, and I think many people preferred the Gentiane Blanche as well. Kevin did not like either of them, so there you are :-)

  3. Joe says:

    Hey Robin… since you don’t care for Gentiane Blanche, I’m not surprised you don’t love Narcisse Bleu. However, I consider Gentiane a staple, and have already bought a giant bottle (at discount, to split) of Narcisse.

    I realized last night that I consider both of these new colognes to be absolutely flankers of other Hermès colognes as (to my nose), they each share a good 70% of their DNA with their respective siblings:
    – Narcisse Bleu is a flanker of Gentiane, with a more floral and green character, but still woody and almost bitter in a way that I love.
    – Mandarine Ambrée I consider a flanker to the Oranges Vertes, and more similar to the Concentré than the Eau. You rightly point out that it probably has elements of Pamplemousse Rose. I do enjoy the vanillic amber that underscores the citrus though. Still, I find it so similar to CdOV — and because there is no dearth of orange scents — that I’m not sure I’d buy Mandarine. It’s definitely well done, though.

    I love the Hermès aesthetic, so this sort of stealth flanker maneuver doesn’t bother me. It’s sort of the opposite of the common practice of launching flankers that share almost nothing with their parents. I find that interesting, but again, I’m not bothered, though the new, unique names sort of belie the fact that these are fairly unoriginal creations.

    • Robin says:

      All good points, and yes, can see the link between OV & MA and even more so between GB & NB. Actually sort of odd to me how MA/PR line up and GB/NB line up…one classic, one modern in each set. I guess it’s sensible to cover all the bases, still.

  4. Dawnkana says:

    Thank you for your review, Robin.

    I will sample this one next I time I am out and about. My favorite is Osmanthe Yunnan for summer. I have never found another Hermes scent to top that one.

    Dawn

    • Robin says:

      OY is so wonderful. I do wish it was cheaper! I had 100 ml and it’s nearly gone.

  5. annemarie says:

    I hope I get a chance to try these two. In the meantime I was thinking that Sur le Nil pulls off that intriguing trick of proloning the citrus and fruity notes for an unexpectedly long time.

    It’s winter for me so summer colognes are out of the question right now, but dear me, a shampoo from Avon, no less, strongly reminds me of that citrusy/fruity whoosh of pleasure I get from Nil: Avon Naturals Lime and Green Tea 2-in-1 shampoo and conditioner. Makes me happy.

    • Robin says:

      Yes, it really does, and for me, fulfills pretty much the same function as a summer cologne anyway.

  6. Omega says:

    Wanting to try that amber one, thanks for the review:).

  7. Abyss says:

    I tried these a couple of times now and neither is probably a must own but I thought that both had interesting and likeable opening notes. I liked that Manarine had a touch of slightly bitter zest mixed in with that sweet juiciness although I didn’t adore the drydown. Narcisse was an interesting one although I’m still trying to figure out what other scent it reminds me of. I thought that in had that general JCR-for-Hermès vibe about it so maybe it was just that.

    Also, when I mentioned that I was a fan of JCE but liked smaller bottles, a Hermès SA told me that there should be some kind of set/coffret of several Hermès perfumes + notes from JCE coming out soon.

  8. hajusuuri says:

    I got samples of Eau de Mandarine Ambrée and Eau de Narcisse Bleu. I tried Mandarine and I’m not wowed by it which is uncharacteristic when it comes to Hermes fragrances. I am getting more passion fruit than mandarin and overall, it felt too thin. I have yet to try Eau de Narcisse Bleu on skin and will do so as soon as I find skin time…slim pickings with so many events taking up my weekends and I (almost) never test on a work day as I don’t want to get stuck with something yucky all day.

    • hajusuuri says:

      I meant to mention that my Nordstrom has both Eau de Mandarine Ambrée and Eau de Narcisse Bleu in the Men’s fragrance section!

      • Robin says:

        Interesting. They do that a lot with unisex stuff — mine even has the Jardins over the men’s side.

    • Omega says:

      I was thinking it may be on the thin side, meh. Thanks for your thoughts:).

    • Robin says:

      As I said above, Kevin really wasn’t wowed either. He thought they were both dull.

      Really, Narcisse is so mild that I wouldn’t think it would matter when you tested it. But we know how that works out — if you hate it, it will be like plutonium.

  9. Persolaise says:

    Firstly, thanks very much for the kind link. :-)

    I’m glad this scent is getting some more love. I think it must be difficult to make citrus compositions seem fresh and interesting and Ellena has risen to the challenge well.

    I have to say I really like Narcisse too, but for totally different reasons.

    • Robin says:

      De nada. Agree, it is getting harder & harder given how many brands are doing them.

  10. Lucy says:

    I finally got to try this yesterday. Based on the descriptions, I thought I would like Narcisse Bleu more, but found myself pleasantly surprised by the Mandarine Ambree. Hermes seems to have mastered the bright and cheerful opening.

Leave a reply